E71: Recruiting Week: Which personality is best?

December 29, 2023


 How can businesses figure out the best personality traits for successful salespeople?

The first stage of building a success sales team (or getting into a sales role) is the recruiting/hiring process.


Could have started with this as the first week but had to build up to the recruiting topic.


To start this week let’s talk about which personality makes for the best salesperson to hire for inside sales.

  • Show Transcript

    Welcome to a new week on the sales experience podcast.


    This is episode 71 starting off recruiting week. If you’re new to the show, if you’re new to the podcast, this is the first time you’ve been listening, then thank you for being here first off, second, my goal is to go through a theme this week, recruiting. Maybe you’re in sales, new to sales, maybe you’re a sales manager or maybe you found this episode and this podcast because you’re in recruiting.


    Maybe you’re a hiring manager, maybe you’re in HR and you either know the challenges of hiring for salespeople for an organization or you’re trying to be proactive and look out for those issues that might come up so you can handle them better from the beginning. Either way, thank you for being here. If you’re a long time listener, I appreciate it. You might be listening to the show, maybe you’re not in a recruiting standpoint.


    However, my goal has been for every episode to apply in some way to anybody that’s in a sales role. So even if you’re a salesperson or if you’re a sales manager this week on recruiting should still have some value for you because if you’re a sales person, you may want to know either why did I get selected or what was it about my personality, my traits, what I went through that got me the job, or, you know, what could help me be more successful in this role?


    Or if I were to transition to another company, what should I keep in mind? What should I focus on either that they are looking for or that I’m looking for as a salesperson and obviously for sales managers, it’s good to know how people are coming on board. Who’s the best person for your role and what it takes to win on your team.


    Let’s jump into this first episode of recruiting week. My focus today is on personality and behaviours. Okay. I covered a lot of that during the behaviour weeks. There was two weeks of that where I covered the four different types of analysts, promoter controllers, supporter. We’re talking about personalities. What kind of person would be best?


    Now my goal, if you’re looking for the answer, if you’re looking for the one perfect solution from me, if you tuned in today to go, wow, please tell me the answer. I don’t have it. However, this is more of a conversation where I want to have you think about what is the ideal personality of the salesperson that you found in your organization works best? Who is it that you have seen is successful?


    Now, one way to do that is to just know and understand who it is, what works best. Because in some organizations, in some sales roles for certain products or services, whether it’s B to c or B to be there, you’re gonna want a hunter, a killer type personality, a go getter who’s just going to go out there and dominate and be controlling and just push hard.


    Other ones, you might want a more analytical, technical sales type person. The classic promoter personality is great, everybody likes that, but that may or may not fit well with your product or service like I was talking about last week. You’ve got to be careful that somebody doesn’t come across too salesy and trigger the prospects to not want to buy or to become more defensive from the beginning.


    So a promoter type person may or may not be a fit for what you have to sell. The key is to understand for your organization, for your corporate culture, for what you’re selling, how it’s being sold, whether it’s face to face, over the phone, short sales cycle, long sales cycle, medium sales cycle.


    You’ve got to know what works best. If you don’t know, if you’re not sure what works, then what I always suggest, and I’ve done this several times with organizations, is to work backwards and reverse engineer the ideal Rep.


    Here’s what I suggest best steps to do is find yourself some kind of computer based testing platform and if you need a suggestion, send me an email or a contact request through the cutter consulting group.com website or find me on LinkedIn.


    Send me a message. Just put in that message, looking for computer based testing, personality tests, suggestion, something along those lines and then I’ll get back to you with what I’ve used and what I have found works the best. What you want to do is you want to pick a test that is inclusive enough for your organization, what you’re looking at a deep level.


    Again, if you have entry level sales people, you don’t need to go deep. If you have really professional, long term salespeople who are going to be with you for a long time, there’s a six month ramp up and training cycle.


    Then you’re obviously going to be more selective and go more in depth with your testing. Find that testing that would fit for you. Then what you want to do is test everybody on your current sales floor, on the team.


    Have everyone take this test, okay? Get the results. Then what you want to do is you want to match up the results with their actual sales performance and their key performance indicator metrics that you have that you’re tracking. If you have 50 reps, if you have a hundred reps, whatever that is, you want to have them all take the test and you want to match that up, sync that up in like excel unless the testing platform has a way to sync that up for you.


    Then you want to analyse where everyone falls into that. You want to sort your reps now with both data sets combined where it’s sorted from high performance to low performance in the metrics that you care about most.


    Yes, it’s generally the number of closed deals but it could be closed deals plus compliance plus revenue, you know whatever that is for you. You want to sort that from high to low. Then what you want to do is you want to look at the testing results and you want to look for patterns and try to identify where the top reps are coming from. Personality, behaviour, traits wise.


    You know if you also test them on computer based skills, math skills, problem solving, you know you can integrate a bunch of tests at once and kind of see where people fall. Where do you want to do is you want to identify and draw the line in the sand on your spreadsheet where the top performers are the middle and then the bottom, and then look for patterns of personalities or behaviours.


    Where do they fall and if there’s any groupings in my experience there generally is there’s certain traits that you see that the top performers, let’s say the top third, right, not even going to 80 20 rule.


    Say the top third of the performers are going to have some common traits. The middle third will have some common traits where maybe it’s based you okay on the same test. The top performers do well in a category and then the bottom is not doing as well, so you have this three sections or whatever makes sense for your organization. Then what you want to do is taking that not to make any changes with your current staff.


    Phase two is to then roll that test out to new hires and candidates before you even bring them on board before you make a higher end decision. Have them take that test, see how they score relative to now, what you’re holding them to and where you would expect them perform.


    If you have the opportunity. Ideally what you want to do is hire some people who are in the categories you think would be a good fit.


    Have them perform the job, hire them, have them go through the paces like anyone else and see how their performance is a month, three months, six months later if that holds up. Now you’ve got your hiring strategy of the personalities, because keep in mind, one of the challenges when you’re hiring salespeople is if they’re good at it, they’re good salespeople.


    They will convince you. They will be convincing, persuasive, maybe even manipulating. They will bring out their abilities to sell and sell you on why you should hire them. That is not necessarily the best strategy. Of course, when you’re hiring a salesperson, you want them to ask you during the interview, you know, if this is a good fit, when can I start? Right?


    You want them to hit you with closing questions. However, sometimes too much of a closing personality, too aggressive, too controlling, might not be good for your culture, for your product or service for your sales process, whatever that looks like.


    So keep in mind, you want to be strategic with which personality works best because just hiring the dominant salesperson with a long resume of experience and closing lots of deals may not be the best fit for you. That’s it for this episode. Hopefully that helps in your recruiting efforts, on narrowing down what kind of people you should have on your campaigns in your company, on your sales team.


    Make sure to subscribe so you can get the rest of these episodes every day when they come out five days a week. iTunes, Stitcher, Spotify, Soundcloud, it’s on Google, it’s on the website. Again, cutter consulting group.com go there, send me a message through the site or LinkedIn. You can find it there with lots of posts, articles, everything sales related. I put most of the content out on there.


    Always, remember that everything in life is sales and people remembered the experience you gave them.


Become a Certified Authentic Persuader

Get the ebooks to help you close more deals

Visit Selling Effectiveness for more tips and get help

Follow Jason on LinkedIn

Or go to Jason’s HUB – www.JasonCutter.com


By Jason Cutter February 26, 2025
How Can You Predict The Future Of Sales Ops? One of the keys to sales success is to be able to predict the future – what that other person is thinking, what they might say, what they will experience, how they will feel about the product/service. But what can you do – from a sales ops leadership perspective – to predict the future in masse of all the potential customers that will flow into and out of the sales process/funnel? That is a really tough one, but it is doable. Meeting Prospective Customers Where They Are The key is to always meet the prospective customers where they are and with the experience they hope to find. It’s a common theme now in these articles because it’s important AND widely disregarded – your potential customers do not care about you, your sales team, your company, your industry. They don’t care about your stats, your testimonials, your logos. They don’t care about your mission statement or your values. They only care about themselves. They also firmly believe that there is currently unlimited choice for any product/service, which means that everything in their mind is a commodity. Easily replaceable and interchangeable. Nothing (other than iPhones…which you can only get from Apple) is special to consumers unless they feel like it should be special. Are You Still Making It All About You? There is a good chance you are still running a marketing, sales funnel that is all about you. I bet if I looked at your company’s website that from the top down it’s all about you (the company). How great you are. What you do for people. What you have done for others. I bet if I tried to speak with your sales team, I will be made to go through your process whether I like it or not. Maybe fill out a form and wait for a response. Or made to call into a toll free number, even though I don’t want to talk to someone yet. Or made to use a chat widget on a site to get started. I bet when I speak with your sales team, 70-80% of the conversation will be about them, your company, and how amazing you all believe you are. This is all fair. No one starts a company to be mediocre. The goal is to provide value and make money. The missing piece, again like I said above, is no one cares about your goals. They only care about themselves. Predicting What Customers Want From The Sales Experience Back to your mission as sales ops leader – predict what massive amounts of prospective customers are going to want from the Sales Experience. It’s why I wrote about it last week and even offered up a book for free to help in any way that I can. To succeed at your mission, you have to stay ahead of the curve of what the public, and specifically – your buying demographic, psychographic, and valuegraphics, want from that experience. Key Questions To Shape The Sales Experience Do they want to call, text, email or chat? Probably all of them…so can you offer each one? (Don’t make someone decide if they want to go through your hoops…remove all the hoops) Do they need to see pricing online – should it be available and transparent? (In most cases, yes) What sales process will be ideal for moving the most people through the sales conversation to a successful outcome? (More discovery, empathy, active listening. More front-loaded about them, not you. Use the Authentic Persuasion Pathway as your model) Who are the decision makers? Is that individual going to decide or do they need to check with others for approval? (Set them up for success, and don’t force them to make a decision in the moment – you will just lose the potential sale) What type of follow up do they want and need until they make the buying decision? What type of post-purchase follow up would go above and beyond a) their expectations and b) what others in your industry do? If there is an ‘onboarding’ stage after the sale – how can you make that actually customer centric and successful? (It is rarely both) Can You Stay Ahead of the Curve? Remember – evolution is natural. The buying public is always evolving their desired sales experience. Can you predict the future of what they want so that when they encounter your company it matches what they were hoping to find – both in the experience and the solution to their need?
By Jason Cutter February 25, 2025
How do you, as a sales leader, help your team become Oracles that can predict the future? [make sure to read the Selling Effectiveness article this week https://go.sellingeffectiveness.com/LI.2.25.AM ] There are five ways to facilitate their Oracle-ness. Be Present in the Moment First, you have to get your salespeople to be in the moment. The challenge that most salespeople (and…humans, for that matter) experience is they are always thinking ahead. Salespeople default to thinking about what they will say next. The next part of their script or process. The next question they want to ask so they can get through discovery. The next part of the agreement they need to discuss and review. Their mind is too busy thinking about what they are going to say and do next, that they aren’t present. As weird as it sounds, if you want to predict the future you must be present. I have said this for decades: the moment you no longer need to think about what you are going to say/do next and can actually be present with your prospect and truly listen to what they say (and don’t say) – you will become a sales professional. Master Active Listening Second is Active Listening and paying closer attention. It’s actively listening…it’s taking what I mentioned above and putting into place. First step is to be present, second is to actually listen. For what they say. For what they aren’t saying. For changes in their tone. For when they are talking to someone on the side – who are they talking to, and is it about your sales conversation? If you sell in person, reading their body language and facial expressions. You must help them develop an almost sixth sense of listening (and yes, I know hearing is one of our senses…but this goes beyond hearing…it’s truly, deeply listening). Ask Better Questions Third, is to help them ask better questions. So many people in sales ask the discovery questions they are required to ask in order to check the discovery ‘box’. Or, they have done sales long enough they know all the answers, they think they know what everyone wants and why, so no reason to even ask questions. [Note – this type of salesperson thinks two dangerous things: 1 - everyone is the same and wants the same thing, 2 – people like to be sold to.] When your team asks better, deeper discovery questions with a focus on uncovering the what and the WHY, they will get better answers. Remember this – when you ask the right questions and you listen close enough, each prospect will tell you EXACTLY how to help them buy. Build Up Experience Fourth, build up experience. If you want to predict the future it comes from enough experience to know the probability of what will happen. For example, when I am in a season of commuting from home to an office, I am the type of person that can predict exactly what will happen on the freeway. Which lane is always faster around certain exits, which lanes always slow down, how much leaving five minutes later can make the drive suck a lot more. How do I know what will happen on a freeway with hundreds and hundreds of random people? Because of experience (and the fact that most people are just going through the motions in life so they become predictable). The more experience your team has with sales scenarios, they more they can predict the future. I generally see that it takes about six months for most people in a new sales role to have seen enough scenarios where they can start to know what will come next before it happens. Trust Intuition The fifth and final trait to help them with is intuition. One definition of intuition is “a thing that one knows or considers likely from instinctive feeling rather than conscious reasoning.” It’s that feeling you get when you know something, even if you cannot explain it. It’s what Malcom Gladwell wrote about in Blink! It’s what we do very well as humans, even if we don’t listen to it. The more you can help your team tune into their intuition and listen and trust it – the better they will do in helping persuade that other human. This goes back to the first suggestion – about being present. When your team trusts they know what to do and say next and they are mentally living in the moment with that prospective client, they can let their intuition guide them. Conclusion When I do trainings, public speaking, facilitating meetings, interviews, and sales – this is my main key to success. I trust and know that I have the experience to handle whatever comes my way in the present moment, while also knowing the destination I am heading towards. I can be present, let that experience and my intuition guide me instead of getting stuck in my head and worrying about what I will say next. Get your team to do some or all of these five steps – and they will become an amazing Oracle.
By Jason Cutter February 25, 2025
The Oracle’s Role in The Matrix If you have seen the Matrix movies, starring Keanu Reeves (as Neo), then you are familiar with an Oracle. In the movies, the Oracle knows what will happen. She has seen it, and it is predestined. In the Oracles mind there is no such thing as free will. In the first Matrix movie, Neo goes to visit her and knocks a vase off the shelf, and it hits the ground and breaks. Right before he hits it, she says “Don’t worry about the vase.” Neo says, “How did you know?” Then the Oracle responds with “What’s really going to bake your noodle later on, is would you still have broken it if I hadn’t said anything.” Becoming an Oracle in Sales Your mission as a sales professional is to be an Oracle for your prospects and clients. To know the future. Then be able to see around corners, as they say. Which means you know what is going to happen before it happens, because you have enough experience that you have become a psychic. You want to be able to predict, with amazing accuracy: What will happen next What will happen after that What issues will pop up What your prospect/client is thinking before they think it What concerns they might have before they have them Eliminating the Fear of the Unknown During your presentation/demo you want to set the expectation of what is going to occur next. Remember, humans fear the unknown. They want to avoid risk as much as possible. Your sales presentation is risky and dangerous and very unknown. They don’t know if you have good intentions or not. Are you going to persuade them? Are you going to try to manipulate them? Are you going to overcharge them? Will you actually care about what they need and want? Dealing with salespeople is so scary. Yet they still need and/or want something, so it’s the dangerous game they must mentally play. Guiding the Buyer Step by Step When you explain what you are going to do in part 1 of your process, and then what that part is done you let them know the plan for part 2, and so on – they will be at ease in the moment. They will feel like they have control over this portion, that there is an exit they can take if they don’t want to proceed. That level of control will help them accept the risk of part 1, and part 2, and part 3. Tell them what you will do. Do it. Tell them what you did. This will validate that you can be trusted. Predicting Thoughts and Feelings The next level is being able to predict what they will think and feel before they do. You can use this information in your presentation (without telling them what you are doing). You can also verbalize it, which could sound like “I am guessing from experience that you are probably wondering about _____, so let’s cover that right now.” Or “most people I speak with ask about _____.” They will think – wow this person knows what I am thinking, he/she is in my mind! And that’s a good thing. A really good thing. Conclusion The more they feel like you know what you are doing, know what they are thinking, know what they are afraid of – the more they trust you as a Guide. Because Guides only know what they know because they have helped other Heros successfully accomplish their journeys. Your mission as a sales professional: Become an Oracle.
By Jason Cutter February 19, 2025
What does it take to build the ideal Sales Experience? Why does it even matter? Maybe you think you already have one. You are a professional sales ops leader. You have put everything you can in place to help your salespeople sell more. You have optimized the processes so that your sales team can focus on one thing – selling. But I promise – even if you think all of that is true, it’s not. The Reality: No Perfect Sales Experience Exists I have never seen any company or team with the ‘ideal’ Sales Experience and operation. And to be honest – I have never built one successfully. Why would I admit that? Because the ideal Sales Experience is aspirational and business, teams, processes, and customer needs/desires are constantly changing. So as soon as you put new processes in place, something else needs to change and evolve. The Scalable Sales Success Iceberg In my Scalable Sales Success Iceberg – there are 24 categories that, when built out, create a scalable sales machine – where you can add in an input and get way more output. I would love to see companies have all 24 categories set up and running optimally. But that’s not even possible – because, as I mentioned, things are always changing. Focusing on the Biggest Levers Here is the key – to build the ideal Sales Experience takes focus on the biggest levers. The ones that, when pulled, create the biggest and best results. There are many processes and systems that you can put in place – but those are going to get you a few percentage points of improvement. Instead of putting it all in here, I want to make you a special offer. Email me at jason@sellingeffectiveness.com with your mailing address, and I will mail you the book that I co-wrote with Nick Glimsdahl called Reasons Not To Focus On The Sales Experience. It will be your starter guide, facilitating the creation of your ideal Sales Experience.
By Jason Cutter February 18, 2025
The Numbers Game Mentality is a Losing Strategy Sales is no longer a “numbers game.” You cannot succeed, long term, by focusing on volume of activity. Making a million dials, sending a million emails, knocking on a million doors (the first two are way easier than that last one) is a scorched earth strategy that will sink your business. You can’t out-dial a bad sales process. It will lead to even more bad online reviews. You can’t out-email a terrible sales funnel process that requires people to jump through poorly planned hoops. You can’t out-knock your way past slimy tactics and bad products/services. The Danger of the "Every No Gets Me Closer to a Yes" Mindset The whole “every no gets me one step closer to a yes” mentally is dangerous. That mindset and strategy assumes that it’s a numbers game. That the only thing that matters is finding the right person who will buy from you. Potentially, no matter what you even say – they are just ready to buy. Not only will this destroy any online reputation you have it will also wreak havoc on your team. It is the fastest and best way to burn out your team. It will lead to a revolving door or hiring, training, and quitting as people realize how unfun the game is you have built and how hard it is to be successful. It will also feel like a mismatch – very few people (and hopefully even less over time) are long-term excited about the business model of calling 500 people a day in hopes of making a few sales. If It’s Not a Numbers Game, Then What Is It? It’s quality over quantity. [Now…note – it does take a certain quantity of activity to fill a sales pipeline. So I am not saying that your sales team can just sit and wait for people to fall into their pipeline with money in hand.] It’s about the Sales Experience. It’s about your team ensuring that they are providing the right and best experience for that potential customer – in a way that sets them up to get into the buying mood and mode. All that matters is the Sales Experience. How can you support your team in terms of the quantity of activity to fill a pipeline, and then the quality of interaction that leads to sales? What Does an Ideal Sales Experience Look Like? What does that look like – the ideal Sales Experience? It’s when your team understands that the potential customer they are speaking with only cares about themselves. They don’t care about the salesperson, your company or the product. They are only focused on themselves. It’s when the Discovery/Empathy portion of the conversation is the most important part. Does your team realize that everything after Discovery – when done right – is just a presentation of the solution? It’s the fact that when you combine the parts of the Authentic Persuasion Pathway (Rapport + Empathy + Trust + Hope + Urgency) that the assumptive close is all you need. If your team is having to ask for the sale they are doing sales wrong. And don’t confuse earning the right to close with asking for the sale. The Sales Leader’s Role in Creating a World-Class Sales Experience Your job as a sales leader is to ensure your team understands that the only thing – above all else – is the sales experience they provide to each potential customer. That customer knows that they have the power and the feeling of unlimited choice. Which means they will decide who to give their money to based on the experience they have with buying from a company. How can you shift your team away from the numbers game mentality to actually providing a world class sales experience to each and every person they speak with?
By Jason Cutter February 17, 2025
The Abundance of Options Today we all have lots of options. While writing this I could speak into my phone and order whatever I want. I can get food delivered before I finish writing this article. I could get a TV delivered to my door before I wake up tomorrow. When someone wants to buy something, they are armed with as much information as they want to access. They can research, read reviews, and watch videos about a product or company. The Shift in Power to the Buyer Because of this, the power balance of sales has shifted away from the salesperson and company to the buyer. Knowledge is power – and they now have all the knowledge they want. With knowing that they have ultimate choice of what to buy (internet and globalization has led to the ability to order anything you want from anywhere…so you are no longer limited to the stores you can drive to and what they have on hand), it means that everything is a commodity in their minds. Nothing is unique or special. Everything is interchangeable. Does the Sales Experience Even Matter? So, this means the sales experience doesn’t matter anymore. There is no reason to put effort into the sales process, the conversations with potential customers. No value in spending time trying to ‘help’ people – since they just view products, salespeople, and companies as interchangeable. You are not special, so there is no benefit in caring. They will walk into your store, and they will decide what they want. They fill out your online for, and they decide if they answer when you call and how the call will go. They walk up to your event/booth, and they decide how the interaction will go and if they want to listen to your elevator pitch. They will let you know if they are interested in moving forward. They will let you know how they want to buy. So, like I said above, there is no real value anymore in the sales experience. Or could it actually be valuable? Is it possible that all that matters IS the sales experience? If people feel they have ultimate information and control of the buying process, how do they decide on what to buy and who to buy from? When I search on Amazon for a product type I have never purchased before, how do I pick? When I want to go shopping for garden supplies for the house, how do I pick where to go? When I need to buy a new fridge, who will I hand my money over to? The cheapest place with terrible service? The place with reasonable prices and great service? The Sales Experience Shapes the Decision I choose based on the sales experience that I will receive. With everything else being equal, I (and I believe most people) will select the place to shop at or the products to buy online based on the experience I receive. To me all that matters is the experience. While I am trying to buy something. Once I receive it – ensure it does what I need it to do. With the feeling of unlimited choices, it can actually be harder now to buy something that in the past. People get into analysis paralysis more often. Which means that for consumers to buy something new they need help. They need a professional salesperson. They need a sales experience that matches their expectations. They want a guide who will help them make the right decision for them, with an experience that goes above and beyond what more people receive any more when they walk into a store, call a company’s toll-free number, or visit a website and have to fill out a form. If you want to succeed in sales – the only thing that matters is the sales experience you provide.
Show More